We have 4 furbabies aka dogs ( Kitty (2 3/4 yrs), Effy (2 yrs), Willow (1 1/2 yrs) and Kismet (8 months) ) who all go a little nutty for Crunch Ears by Honey! I'm Home. These are a great treat/chew that for our girls last them somewhere between a Honey! I'm Home Paddywack and Bullystick, which means anywhere from 30 minutes to 3 hours depending on the day. Our girls love their flavor and we love that they are healthful, medium long lasting and safe treat for our girls. These are a treat we buy in bulk and keep in stock in our home at all times, so we DEFINITELY RECOMMEND!